Air Fryer vs Deep Fryer: The Best Cooking Method Debate

We recommend the best products we think will help our visitors. All opinions expressed here are our own. This website contains affiliate links that at no additional cost to you, and we may earn a small commission. Read our full privacy policy here.

There is an age-old debate of which frying method reigns supreme: air fryer vs deep fryer. 

We at the Cooktop Hunter have no intention of solving this great mystery, but we can tell you what each has to offer and help you decide which one might be the best option for your needs! 

Over the years, people have debated which frying method is best. There are many factors that go into deciding how to fry food: health benefits, taste difference, crunch-level, and time needed for cooking…the list goes on and on. So today, we’ll explore the similarities and differences between air frying vs deep frying.

Air Fryer Vs Deep Fryer – What’s The Difference? 

Air fryers and deep fryers are two of the most popular types of cooking appliances. Although they both cook food by heating oil to a high temperature, their similarities end there. 

Both are indeed great kitchen appliances that save time in the cooking process, however, their differences can’t be ignored. The air fryer cooks food with rapid air circulation while a deep-fryer uses oil to heat up foods for crispier results.

frying food in oil

When Should You Use An Air Fryer?

The air fryer is used to make delicious food, but it’s important to know when you should use one. It’s perfect for cooking foods that are high in fat.

I am one of those who agrees that the food when air frying vs deep frying taste virtually indistinguishable. The best part about it is that it can also be a great way for people who have been craving fried food but want to practice healthier habits and still enjoy their favorite foods without feeling bad about themselves. It’s a win-win!

When Should You Use A Deep Fryer?

Deep fryers are a great addition to any kitchen. Deep frying is a great way to cook for parties or special occasions because all you have to do is fill your fryer with oil and set the temperature.

One of the best things about frying food in your classic, trusty deep fryer is that it creates extra crispy results on everything from chicken wings to full chickens. Plus, if you’re using something with longer cooking time like whole chickens then there’s no better way than breaking out this classic kitchen tool and enjoying an amazing meal!

Air Fryers: What Is It And How Does It Work?

If you’re wondering, “Are air fryers good?”, then I can tell you that they are. An air fryer is a countertop kitchen appliance that allows you to cook food with little or no added oil. 

woman cooking food in air fryer

I know, you’re probably thinking, how does an air fryer work? To put it simply, it works by heating up hot air which is circulated over the food to cook it. This is done to cook your food more quickly and evenly, with less oil than you would use in traditional frying methods. 

When it comes to the best air fryers like the Ninja AF101 Air Fryer, you can enjoy oil-free fryer recipes like french fries, chicken wings, and even pizza rolls but without the excess fat in just minutes!

Ninja AF101 Air Fryer, 4...
27,525 Reviews
Ninja AF101 Air Fryer, 4...
  • Now enjoy guilt free food; Air fry with up to 75 percent less fat than traditional frying methods; Tested against hand cut, deep...
  • Wide temperature range: 105 degree Fahrenheit to 400 degrees Fahrenheit allows you to gently remove moisture from foods or quickly...
  • 4 quart ceramic coated nonstick basket and crisper plate fit 2 pounds of french fries. Cord length (feet) - 2.6
  • The unit will need time to preheat before coming up to temperature. We recommend that you preheat the unit for 3 minutes before...
  • Dehydrate: Create flat, chip like dehydrated foods for fun, homemade snacks pounds; The combination of low fan speed and low...

Last update on 2021-09-28 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Deep Fryers: What Is It And How Does It Work?

A deep fryer may seem like an odd appliance you need at home if there isn’t much room left over from your oven, stovetop pan collection, and slow cooker! But this small kitchen tool has many advantages beyond just being able to make “fried” foods quickly. 

Deep fryers are appliances that help us cook fried foods by immersing the food in hot oil. The mechanism is simple: a basket on top, an insert at the bottom that holds water/oil (which must be heated first), and then have controls for temperature settings as well as time durations.

The best deep fryer like the T-Fal Deep Fryer will heat the liquid to at least 350 degrees Fahrenheit before it starts boiling which allows you to deep-fry your favorite snacks!

T-fal Deep Fryer with...
10,569 Reviews
T-fal Deep Fryer with...
  • POWERFUL PERFORMANCE: Powerful 1700 watt deep fryer with 3.5 liter oil capacity and 2.65 pound food capacity to offer friends and...
  • EASY TO USE: With 2 position basket for cooking and draining food; Handles for easy transportation and storage
  • PATENTED OIL FILTRATION SYSTEM: EZ Clean oil filtration system for convenient deep frying, cost savings, and simple oil storage
  • PROFESSIONAL RESULTS: Professional and healthier results thanks to the immersed heating element that quickly recovers oil...
  • DISHWASHER SAFE: Easy to clean with dishwasher safe parts

Last update on 2021-09-28 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Can Air Fryers Cook Healthier Food Than Deep Fryers?

When it comes to air fryer vs deep fryer calories, the air fryer definitely takes the cake. Air fryers use hot air and an element to cook the food, which means you can enjoy crispy French fries without worrying about excessive fat and calories. In fact, French fries have only about 30% of their original calorie count after being cooked with this method!

On the other hand, submerging your food in piping hot oil, while it makes it extra crunchy, also allows it to absorb half its weight in extra fat. 

Do Fried Food Taste Better In Air Fryers Or Deep Fryers?

Air frying has become an alternative way for people who love traditional cooking methods but would prefer a less greasy meal. But what difference does it make from traditional deep frying when it comes to taste?

cooking french fries in a deep fryer

Air frying Vs Deep Frying: Which Tastes Better?

Fried foods cooked in an air fryer vs deep fryer taste equally delicious, but there are some subtle differences. For example, foods cooked in an air fryer retain more of their flavor because they aren’t sitting in oil for so long. This means that you can enjoy crispy foods with just the right amount of seasoning – not too much and not too little!

Meanwhile, deep-fried foods tend to lose a lot of their moisture due to exposure to high heat which makes them taste drier than when fried using an air fryer.

Do French Fries Taste Better When Air-fried Than Deep-fried?

Yes! Who knew that air-fried french fries taste even better than their deep-fried counterparts? The fryer cooks them quickly and evenly, making for a crispy exterior with a tender interior. 

Can You Cook Faster In An Air Fryer Than In A Deep Fryer?

In a comparison between air fryer vs deep fryer cooking time, air fryer is a clear winner. Air fryers are fantastic for people who love to cook but hate the amount of time it takes. It cooks food up to three times faster than other cooking methods. Therefore, you can start your air frying session immediately after turning on the machine with little-to-no preheating required unlike cooking with a deep fryer. 

Is It Easier To Clean And Maintain An Air Fryer Or Deep Fryer?

Clean-up is a breeze with air fryers since there’s practically no mess. The machine comes with its own filter so you don’t have to worry about cleaning out the oil residue or trying to figure out how much to use every time – just pop in the filter and it will do all that for you!

Using Air Fryer

On the other hand, the fact that deep-frying requires more oil than air frying does automatically makes cleaning up after cooking a hassle. If you’re not careful, the used oil can spill everywhere and it’s a real pain to clean.

In air fryer vs deep fryer maintenance, air fryers win hands down! For example, air fryers don’t require you to change their oil very often – only once every couple of months. Meanwhile, deep fryers will need you to change their oil more often – about once a week, depending on how frequently you use it.

People Also Ask:

Does Air Frying Taste As Good As Deep Frying?

Air frying might taste just as good, if not better than deep-frying. Unlike deep frying, air-frying doesn’t make food soggy. It uses less fat to get the same crispy texture that you can only get from deep-frying.

Which Is Better Deep Fryer Or Air Fryer?

It all depends on what you’re looking for. Deep fryers require more oil and maintain a constant temperature, but air fryers cook food faster and use less oil. Making it not only healthier but also more cost-efficient.

Do Air-fried French Fries Taste Good?

Yes! Air-fried french fries taste just as good, if not better than deep-fried ones. 

cooking potato wedges on air fryer

Are Deep Fry And Air Fry Times The Same?

No. Deep fry times vary depending on the weight and thickness of your food, while air frying only takes about half the time compared to deep frying.

Does An Air Fryer Taste Like A Deep Fryer?

No. Deep frying requires more oil than air frying does, so deep-fried food has a greasier taste compared to the light and crispy goodness you get from air frying.

Can You Use An Air Fryer As A Deep Fryer?

No. Air fryers are designed specifically for air frying – they use less oil, which means it’s not safe to cook with deep-frying methods.

The Conclusion?

If you are looking for a quick, easy way to fry up your favorite comfort foods without all the mess and hassle of using traditional deep-frying methods, then an air fryer may be best for you.

These machines are not only easy to use, but they also allow for healthier cooking methods while still giving food the crunchy texture people love so much about fried foods. Hungry yet? You’ll find plenty more great recipes on our website–check them out!

Leave a Comment